Peanut Butter Banana Pudding: The Creamy, Dreamy Dessert That Feels Like a Hug

Hey, friends! Beau here, welcoming you back to my kitchen. You know me—I’m all about those recipes that don’t just fill your belly but also warm your soul. The ones you can whip up without a fancy culinary degree, the ones that make your people gather around the table a little longer, laughing a little louder. Today, we’re diving headfirst into one of those magical, no-fuss desserts that I absolutely live for: Peanut Butter Banana Pudding.

Now, if you’ve ever had classic Southern banana pudding, you know it’s a masterpiece in its own right. It’s nostalgia in a bowl, a sweet, creamy, and comforting treat that feels like a Sunday afternoon at your grandma’s house. But what happens when you take that beloved classic and give it a little *Feastical* twist? You add a generous, glorious swirl of creamy peanut butter, that’s what.

This isn’t just a recipe; it’s a flavor experience. Imagine layers of vanilla wafers getting soft and cake-like, ripe bananas adding their sweet, mellow fruitiness, and a cloud-like pudding that’s somehow even creamier and more decadent than the original. And then, the star of the show: that rich, nutty, and deeply satisfying peanut butter flavor weaving through every single spoonful. It’s the perfect marriage of two iconic comfort foods, and I promise you, it’s a game-changer for potlucks, family dinners, or those “I just need a little something sweet” moments. So, grab your favorite mixing bowl and let’s make some magic happen!

The Day I Accidentally Created a Family Legend

I have to share a quick story about where this recipe really came from. It was a classic “Beau in the kitchen” moment—a happy accident born from a serious craving and a near-empty pantry. A few years back, I was tasked with bringing dessert to a big family potluck. I had my heart set on banana pudding, but as I started gathering ingredients, I realized I was short on cream cheese, which I sometimes use for extra richness. Panic mode? Almost. But then, my eyes landed on a nearly-full jar of the good stuff: creamy peanut butter.

In a moment of “what’s the worst that could happen?” inspiration, I scooped a big dollop right into the pudding mixture. I gave it a whisk, took a tentative taste, and my eyes just about popped out of my head. It was INCREDIBLE. The peanut butter didn’t overpower the vanilla and banana; it complemented them, adding a salty, nutty depth that made the whole dessert taste… well, more like *itself*, but better. I layered it up, crossed my fingers, and brought it to the party. Let me tell you, it was the first dish to disappear. My cousin’s kids still ask for “Uncle Beau’s Peanut Butter Pudding” at every gathering. It just goes to show that some of the best creations come from a little improvisation and a whole lot of love.

Gathering Your Dream Team: The Ingredients

One of the best things about this recipe is its beautiful simplicity. You probably have most of this in your kitchen right now! Here’s the lineup that creates this creamy dream.

• 1 (5.1 oz) box instant vanilla pudding mix: This is our foundation. It gives us that classic, creamy pudding texture without any fuss. Chef’s Insight: I use instant because it sets quickly and stays light. If you only have cook-and-serve, you can use it, but let it cool completely before moving to the next steps!
• 2 cups cold milk: The key word here is cold. It helps the pudding mix thicken up properly and quickly. Whole milk will give you the richest result, but 2% works great, too.
• 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk: This is the secret weapon for ultra-creamy, decadent pudding. It adds a lovely caramel-like sweetness and a smooth, thick body that’s just irresistible.
• ½ cup creamy peanut butter: Use a standard, no-stir creamy peanut butter for the smoothest incorporation. Substitution Tip: If you’re a crunchy peanut butter fan, go for it! It will add a wonderful little textural surprise in every bite.
• 1 (8 oz) container whipped topping (like Cool Whip), thawed: This folds in to make our pudding mixture light, fluffy, and cloud-like. Chef’s Insight: You can absolutely use an equal amount of freshly whipped heavy cream if you prefer! Just whip 1 ½ cups of heavy cream with a tablespoon of sugar until you get stiff peaks.
• 4 ripe bananas, sliced: Look for bananas that are yellow with a few brown spots—they’re at their peak sweetness and flavor. Pro Tip: Don’t slice them until you’re ready to assemble to prevent browning!
• 1 box vanilla wafer cookies: The classic choice! They provide that iconic soft-yet-slightly-chewy layer that soaks up all the pudding goodness.
• Optional for topping: Crushed peanuts or extra cookies: This is your chance to add a final flourish! A little crunch on top makes for a beautiful presentation and a fantastic textural contrast.

Let’s Build the Dream: Step-by-Step Instructions

Ready to assemble this masterpiece? It’s so simple. Put on some good music, clear a space in your fridge, and let’s get layering.

1. Create the Pudding Base: Grab a large mixing bowl and pour in the cold milk. Sprinkle the entire box of instant vanilla pudding mix over the milk. Now, take your whisk and get to work! Whisk steadily for about 2 minutes. You’ll see it transform from a liquid into a lovely, thick pudding. Chef’s Hack: Don’t over-whisk here! Two minutes is usually perfect. Over-whisking can sometimes make it a bit thin.
2. Incorporate the Richness: Now, pour in that entire can of sweetened condensed milk. See that thick, sweet stream? That’s pure magic right there. Next, add your half-cup of creamy peanut butter. Chef’s Hack: To make the peanut butter easier to mix, give it a quick stir in its jar first. It incorporates into the pudding like a dream. Whisk everything together until it’s completely smooth, creamy, and uniform in color. No streaks of peanut butter left behind!
3. Fold in the Fluff: Time to lighten things up! Grab your thawed whipped topping. Using a spatula, gently fold it into the peanut butter pudding mixture. Chef’s Hack: “Folding” is key here. Instead of stirring vigorously, which would deflate the whipped topping, use a gentle, sweeping motion—down the side of the bowl, across the bottom, and up and over the top. Repeat until you see no more white streaks. Your mixture will be incredibly light and fluffy.
4. The Grand Layering: Get out your trusty 9×13-inch dish—this is the classic vessel for a reason; it gives you the perfect ratio of layers. Start by spreading a thin, even layer of the pudding mixture on the very bottom. This just helps anchor everything. Now, create your first proper layer: a single layer of vanilla wafers, followed by a layer of banana slices (use about half of them), and then a third of your remaining pudding mixture, spreading it gently to cover the bananas. Repeat the layers—wafers, bananas, pudding—one more time. For your final top layer, finish with the remaining pudding mixture, spreading it out beautifully. Pro Tip: Save a few of your best-looking wafers and banana slices for a pretty garnish on top right before serving!
5. The Patience Game (Aka Chilling): This is the hardest part, I know! But trust me, it’s non-negotiable. Cover the dish tightly with plastic wrap and pop it in the fridge for at least 4 hours, but ideally overnight. This waiting period is when the alchemy happens. The wafers soften and become almost cake-like, the bananas release their sweet juice into the pudding, and all the flavors marry into one harmonious, creamy, incredible bite.
6. The Final Flourish: Right before you’re ready to serve, it’s topping time! Sprinkle on some crushed peanuts for a salty crunch, crumble a few extra wafers over the top, or artfully arrange a few fresh banana slices. Then, stand back and admire your creation before you dive in with a big spoon.

How to Serve This Slice of Heaven

Presentation is part of the fun! You can absolutely serve this family-style right from the baking dish—it’s cozy and inviting. But if you want to get a little fancy, here are a few of my favorite ways to plate it up.

For a stunning individual dessert, use a large mason jar or a clear trifle bowl. Simply build the layers directly in the jar for a beautiful, visible parfait effect. It’s a total showstopper at parties!

You can also use a large ice cream scoop to dollop generous servings into wide, shallow bowls. The soft, creamy texture looks gorgeous this way. No matter how you serve it, I love pairing this pudding with a hot cup of coffee or a cold glass of milk. The contrast is just perfect. And remember, this dessert is rich! A little goes a long way, making it perfect for feeding a crowd.

Make It Your Own: Delicious Recipe Variations

One of the best things about a recipe like this is its flexibility. Feel free to play around and make it suit your taste buds or dietary needs!

• The Chocolate Lover’s Dream: Swap the vanilla wafers for chocolate wafer cookies or even crushed Oreos. You could even add a tablespoon of cocoa powder to the pudding mix for a chocolate-peanut butter cup vibe.
• Nutty Twist: Use almond butter or cashew butter instead of peanut butter for a different, equally delicious nutty flavor. Top with toasted sliced almonds or chopped cashews.
• Boost the Banana: For an extra banana punch, mash one very ripe banana and whisk it into the pudding mixture along with the sweetened condensed milk. It intensifies the flavor beautifully.
• Lighter Version: You can use sugar-free instant pudding mix, fat-free milk, and a light whipped topping to cut down on calories and sugar without sacrificing the creamy texture.
• Boozy Banana Pudding (For the Grown-Ups): Add a tablespoon or two of bourbon or banana liqueur to the pudding mixture when you add the sweetened condensed milk. It adds a wonderful, warm depth of flavor.

Beau’s Chef’s Notes & Kitchen Confessions

This recipe has evolved so much since that first panicked potluck creation. I’ve learned that letting it sit overnight is truly the key to transcendent banana pudding. The texture becomes something else entirely—softer, more unified, and just… better.

I also have a funny kitchen confession: I once, in a hurry, tried to use frozen bananas that I had thawed. Big mistake! They released way too much water and made the whole pudding soupy. Learn from my error—always use fresh, ripe (but not mushy) bananas! This dish is a testament to the beauty of simple, high-quality ingredients. It doesn’t need to be complicated to be absolutely unforgettable.

Your Questions, Answered: FAQs & Troubleshooting

I’ve gotten a lot of questions about this pudding over the years, so let’s tackle the most common ones!

Q: Can I make this peanut butter banana pudding ahead of time?
A: Absolutely! In fact, I highly recommend it. Making it the day before you need it is the best way to go. Just hold off on adding any crunchy toppings (like peanuts) until right before serving so they stay crisp.

Q: My pudding seems runny. What happened?
A: Don’t worry! This can happen for a couple of reasons. First, did you use cold milk? Warm milk can prevent the pudding from setting. Second, it might just need more time to chill. The pudding and wafers need those full 4+ hours to set up properly. Pop it back in the fridge and give it more time. It will almost always firm up.

Q: How long will the leftovers last?
A: This pudding is best enjoyed within 2-3 days. The bananas will start to brown and get very soft after that. It’s still safe to eat, but the texture and appearance won’t be at their peak.

Q: Can I use homemade pudding instead of instant?
A: You sure can! Make your favorite cooked vanilla pudding recipe (about 3 cups worth) and let it cool completely to room temperature. Then, proceed with the recipe from step 2, adding the sweetened condensed milk and peanut butter to the cooled homemade pudding.

Peanut Butter Banana Pudding : A Creamy, Dreamy Southern Dessert Twist

---

• Author: BeauCollier

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

Peanut Butter Banana Pudding: Creamy, Dreamy, Soul-Warming Dessert

A luscious twist on the classic Southern banana pudding, layered with peanut butter, bananas, and soft vanilla wafers. Perfect for potlucks, family dinners, or a sweet treat anytime!

---

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

• 1 (5.1 oz) box instant vanilla pudding mix

• 2 cups cold milk

• 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk

• ½ cup creamy peanut butter

• 1 (8 oz) container whipped topping, thawed (or 1 ½ cups whipped heavy cream)

• 4 ripe bananas, sliced

• 1 box vanilla wafer cookies

• Optional topping: crushed peanuts or extra vanilla wafers

---

Instructions

• Make the Pudding Base:
  In a large bowl, whisk cold milk and instant pudding mix for 2 minutes until thickened.

• Add Peanut Butter & Sweetness:
  Stir in sweetened condensed milk and peanut butter until smooth.

• Fold in the Whipped Topping:
  Gently fold in the whipped topping to keep the mixture light and airy.

• Layer the Dessert:

  • Spread a thin layer of pudding in a 9×13-inch dish.

  • Layer vanilla wafers, half of the banana slices, and a third of the pudding mixture.

  • Repeat: wafers, bananas, pudding.

  • Top with remaining pudding. Reserve a few bananas or wafers for garnish.

• Chill:
  Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.

• Add the Final Touch:
  Before serving, sprinkle crushed peanuts or extra wafers on top for texture and visual appeal.

Notes

• Use fresh, ripe bananas—not frozen—to avoid a watery pudding.

• Make ahead for best flavor and texture. Add crunchy toppings just before serving.

• Cold milk ensures instant pudding sets correctly.

Nutrition

• Calories: 310 Cal Per Serving
• Fat: 14 g
• Carbohydrates: 40 g
• Protein: 6 g

Let’s Talk Nutrition (The Real Talk)

Now, I’m a firm believer that dessert is meant to be enjoyed soulfully and without guilt! This Peanut Butter Banana Pudding is a treat, through and through. It’s rich, satisfying, and packed with flavor. Here’s a general breakdown per serving (remember, this is an estimate and can vary based on your specific ingredients).

Per Serving (Approximately):
Calories: 310 | Fat: 14g | Carbs: 40g | Protein: 6g

It does provide a bit of protein from the peanut butter and milk, and bananas offer potassium and fiber. But let’s be real—we’re here for the comfort and the joy it brings. My philosophy is always about balance. Enjoy a generous serving of this at your family BBQ, savor every bite, and then maybe have a lighter meal the next day. Food is fuel, but it’s also love, memory, and celebration. This dessert is definitely a celebration.

Final Thoughts from My Kitchen to Yours

Well, there you have it, my friends—my heart and soul in a pudding dish. This Peanut Butter Banana Pudding is more than just a recipe; it’s a reminder that the best meals and memories are often the simplest ones. It’s about taking a classic, adding your own personal twist, and sharing it with the people you love.

I can’t wait for you to try this. I can already picture you pulling that chilled dish out of the fridge, seeing those perfect layers, and watching the smiles spread around your table. That’s what Feastical is all about. So, go on, make it, share it, and tag me on social media with #Feastical so I can see your beautiful creations! Until next time, happy cooking!

With a full heart and an even fuller spoon,
Beau