Feastical

The Cozy Magic of Homemade Pumpkin Spice (And Why Your Taste Buds Will Thank You!)

Hey friends! Beau here from Feastical, and if there’s one thing that screams “hello, gorgeous fall!” louder than a crackling bonfire, it’s that first whiff of pumpkin spice. You know the one—that warm, cinnamon-kissed hug that turns lattes into liquid sweaters and muffins into edible nostalgia. But let’s be real: store-bought pumpkin spice blends? They’re like a lukewarm handshake compared to the bear hug of a HOMEMADE version. Today, I’m sharing my foolproof, soul-warming pumpkin spice recipe that’ll make your kitchen smell like a Vermont orchard at peak foliage. We’re talking two ways to shake things up: a big batch for my fellow spice addicts (you know who you are!), and a single-serving version for when you’re testing the waters. No fancy equipment, no mysterious additives—just pure, uncomplicated coziness in a jar. Trust me, once you try this, you’ll be sprinkling it on everything from oatmeal to scrambled eggs (yes, really!). So grab your favorite mug and let’s make your spice drawer fall in love with autumn.

That Time I Started a Mini Spice Revolution (AKA My Pumpkin Spice Origin Story)

Picture this: It’s 2015, and I’m hosting my first Friendsgiving. I’d spent hours on a from-scratch pumpkin pie, only to realize I’d run out of pumpkin spice. Panic mode! Desperate, I eyeballed some cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg from my spice rack. The result? My buddy Dave took one bite, slammed his fork down, and declared, “WHAT did you do to this pie? It’s like pumpkin pie woke UP!” Turns out, my haphazard blend had twice the ginger and half the cloves of the store stuff—and everyone lost their minds over that zingy, bold flavor. That little “oops” moment became a tradition. Now, every September, my crew demands “Beau’s Rebel Blend.” We even started gifting jars with cheeky labels like “Spice Traffic Controller” or “Clove Investigator.” Moral of the story? Sometimes the best recipes are born from happy accidents and empty spice jars. Your kitchen, your rules!

Your Spice Squad: Meet the Flavor All-Stars!

Here’s the dream team that makes this blend sing. Pro tip: Spice freshness MATTERS. If your cinnamon smells like dust, it’ll taste like dust. Give your jars a sniff test first!

Large Batch (Makes ~½ cup—perfect for gifting!)

• 6 tbsp ground cinnamon: The cozy backbone! Use Ceylon for floral notes or Cassia for bold warmth. Chef’s hack: Raid the bulk section—it’s cheaper!
• 3 tsp ground ginger: That zippy kick! Prefer less heat? Drop to 2 tsp. Fun fact: Ginger adds depth to savory dishes too—try it in chili!
• 3 tsp ground nutmeg: The sweet, earthy whisperer. For next-level flavor, grate whole nutmeg. It’s a game-changer!
• 1½ tsp allspice: Think cinnamon’s cool cousin with hints of pepper + clove. No allspice? Sub equal parts cinnamon + a pinch of clove.
• 1 tsp ground cloves: The powerhouse! Handle with care—it dominates. Clove-sensitive? Start with ½ tsp and taste.

Single Teaspoon (Doubled for Extra Oomph!)

• 1 tsp ground cinnamon: Your flavor anchor. Got Vietnamese cinnamon? Use it—it’s intense!
• ½ tsp ground ginger: Fresh is best, but powdered works in a pinch.
• ½ tsp ground nutmeg: No fresh nutmeg? No shame—just ensure your jar’s less than a year old.
• 2 pinches allspice: Literally a two-finger pinch! About ⅛ tsp.
• 2 pinches ground cloves: Use your thumb + forefinger. Want more warmth? Add a third pinch!

Mix It, Taste It, Love It: Your Foolproof Spice Journey

Ready to become a spice wizard? Let’s do this! Total time: 2 minutes (unless you stop to sniff the jar repeatedly—no judgment).

1. Gather Your Troops: Line up spices, a small bowl, a tiny whisk (or fork), and an airtight jar. Chef’s hack: Use a funnel to avoid spice-dusting your counter!
2. Measure Like a Scientist (But Have Fun Like a Rebel): Spoon spices into measuring spoons—DON’T scoop from the jar. Why? Packed spices = inaccurate ratios. Level ’em off with a knife. Pro tip: Place a sheet of parchment under your bowl. Spill? Fold parchment and funnel it back in!
3. Whisk with Wild Abandon: Dump everything into your bowl. Now whisk like you’re cheering on your favorite team! 20 seconds minimum. See those ginger clumps? Murder them. Your blend should look like autumn-hued velvet.
4. The Sniff Test of Victory: Inhale deeply. Smell mostly cinnamon? Add 5 more seconds of whisking. Ginger too shy? Dust in an extra pinch. Remember: Flavors meld over 24 hours. It’ll taste even better tomorrow!
5. Jar It Up, Buttercup: Funnel your blend into an airtight jar. Mason jars work, but tinted glass blocks light for longer freshness. Label it with the date—this stuff lasts 6 months, but you’ll use it in 6 weeks!

Beyond the Latte: Let’s Get Creative!

Whip out this blend anytime you crave instant hygge. Stir a teaspoon into your morning oatmeal or yogurt. Dust it over roasted sweet potatoes or butternut squash soup. Bake it into banana bread, cookies, or my famous “Pumpkin Spice Boom!” pancakes (recipe coming soon!). My personal obsession? A sneaky pinch in beef stew—trust me, it adds mysterious depth. And yes, it’s killer in coffee, but try it in hot chocolate or chai for a next-level cozy sip.

Shake Up Your Spice Life: 5 Delicious Twists

Your kitchen, your rules! Try these riffs:

1. “Chai-Spiced” Version: Add 1 tsp cardamom + ½ tsp black pepper (per large batch). Perfect for steeping in milk for homemade chai!
2. “Sugar Kissed” Blend: Mix 2 tbsp brown sugar into large batch. Ideal for rimming cocktail glasses or sprinkling on toast.
3. Clove-Free Zone: Omit cloves entirely + add extra allspice. Great for sensitive palates!
4. “Smoky Maple” Mood: Add 1 tsp smoked paprika (large batch). Killer on roasted carrots or in BBQ rubs.
5. Whole-Spice Wonder: Toast whole cinnamon sticks, ginger, etc., grind in a spice grinder. Fresher = fiercer flavor!

Beau’s Backstage Spice Confessions

True story: I once gifted this blend to my neighbor Brenda, who declared it “too lively” for her famous pumpkin bread. Fast-forward to Thanksgiving—she sheepishly admitted she’d secretly used it and won her church bake-off! Now she buys bulk spices for me to blend. Evolution alert: My original 2015 “Rebel Blend” had DOUBLE the ginger—toned it down for y’all, but feel free to amp it up! Storage tip: Keep it away from heat (not above the stove!). And if you catch me adding a pinch to vanilla ice cream? Mind your business—it’s genius.

Pumpkin Spice 911: Fixes for Common Oopsies!

Q: Help! My blend tastes bitter. Did I ruin it?
A: Clove or allspice can turn bitter if overused. Fix it: Mix in 1-2 extra tbsp cinnamon + 1 tsp sugar. Shake hard!

Q: Can I use pumpkin pie spice instead of this in recipes?
A: Absolutely 1:1 swap! But homemade packs fresher flavor. Store-bought often uses cheaper cinnamon and less ginger.

Q: Why does my spice look lumpy?
A> Ginger loves to clump! Crush lumps with a spoon pre-whisking. Still stubborn? Sift the blend through a fine mesh strainer.

Q: Can I sub fresh ginger for ground?
A: Not in this dry blend—it’ll add moisture and spoil. BUT grate fresh ginger into batters or drinks where you’d use this spice!

Homemade Pumpkin Spice

---

• Author: BeauCollier
• Total Time: 2 mins

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

Skip the store-bought stuff—this 5-ingredient homemade pumpkin spice is warmer, fresher, and infinitely more customizable than anything from a packet. With just cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, and cloves, you can whip up a batch in 2 minutes flat and use it in everything from lattes to roasted veggies. Plus, it makes your kitchen smell like a cozy fall dream!

---

Ingredients

(Large Batch – Great for Gifting!)

• 6 tbsp ground cinnamon (Ceylon for floral, Cassia for bold)

• 3 tsp ground ginger (adjust to taste—more = spicier!)

• 3 tsp ground nutmeg (freshly grated if possible)

• 1½ tsp allspice (or sub cinnamon + pinch of clove)

• 1 tsp ground cloves (use ½ tsp if sensitive to strong clove flavor)

(Single-Serving Teaspoon)

• 1 tsp cinnamon

• ½ tsp ginger

• ½ tsp nutmeg

• 2 pinches allspice (~⅛ tsp)

• 2 pinches cloves (~⅛ tsp)

---

Instructions

1. Mix It Up

• In a small bowl, whisk all spices together until fully combined (30 seconds).

• Break up any clumps (especially ginger!) for a smooth blend.

2. Taste & Adjust

• Dip a finger in—want more warmth? Add a pinch more ginger or cloves.

• Let sit 10 minutes for flavors to meld, then taste again.

3. Store It Right

• Transfer to an airtight jar (mason jar or spice container).

• Label with date—stays fresh for 6 months, but you’ll use it faster!

Notes

✅ For fresher flavor, buy whole spices (cinnamon sticks, nutmeg) and grind them yourself.
✅ Too strong? Cut cloves in half and add extra cinnamon.
✅ Gift idea: Package in mini jars with a tag: “Just add pie.”

• Prep Time: 2 mins

Nutrition

• Calories: 6 Cal Per 1 tsp
• Sugar: 0g
• Carbohydrates: 2g
• Fiber: 1g

Nutritional Nibbles (Per 1 tsp)

• Calories: 6
• Carbs: 2g
• Sugar: 0g
• Fat: 0g
• Fiber: 1g
• Protein: 0g

Note: Spices are antioxidant powerhouses! Cinnamon helps regulate blood sugar, ginger aids digestion—so sprinkle guilt-free.

Final Thoughts: Why Homemade Wins Every Time

Store-bought pumpkin spice isn’t bad—it’s just… lazy. Like using instant coffee when you could have a freshly brewed cup. Making your own lets you:

• Control the quality (no stale spices hiding in the mix).

• Adjust flavors to your taste (more ginger? Less clove? Go wild!).

• Experiment beyond lattes (savory dishes, cocktails, even spiced nuts!).

So next time you reach for that pre-made jar, ask yourself: Do I want a basic autumn, or a legendary one? Your spice drawer (and your taste buds) already know the answer.