Feastical

The Cookie That Started It All: My Thick & Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies

Hey friends, Beau here! Let’s talk about one of life’s simplest, most profound joys: a perfect peanut butter cookie. I’m not talking about those crumbly, dry numbers that leave you reaching for a glass of milk just to get through one. No, no. I’m talking about a cookie that’s a true event. A cookie with a soft, almost brownie-like center, slightly crisp golden edges, and a rich, roasty peanut butter flavor that just *sings*. The kind of cookie that makes you close your eyes for a second after the first bite.

This recipe is my gold standard, my go-to, my “wow, I really nailed it” peanut butter cookie. It’s the one I’ve made for countless potlucks, school bake sales (the ultimate taste-testers!), and those late-night “I deserve a treat” moments. It’s deceptively simple, but a few chef-approved secrets take it from good to legendary. We’re using a beautiful blend of brown sugar for that molasses-y moisture and a specific mixing method to guarantee that perfect, thick, and chewy texture. So, preheat your oven, friends. We’re about to make your kitchen smell like a warm, peanut-buttery hug.

A Spoonful of Nostalgia: Why This Recipe Sticks

Every time I cream together that peanut butter and butter, the smell instantly transports me back to my grandma’s kitchen. Her house always had this magical, slightly chaotic energy, especially on rainy afternoons. The counter would be dusted with flour, and she’d let me “help” by pressing the criss-cross pattern into the dough with a fork. I was convinced I was doing the most important job in the world. Her version was fantastic, but over the years, I’ve tinkered—swapping in more brown sugar, adjusting the flour ratio, and insisting on letting the cookies rest on the baking sheet. It’s her soul with my little chef twists. That’s the beautiful thing about recipes; they’re living stories. This cookie isn’t just a snack; it’s a direct line to a happy memory, and now, I’m so excited to help you start your own.

Gathering Your Cookie Crew: The Ingredients

Simple ingredients, superstar results. That’s the Feastical way! Here’s the dream team that’s going to create cookie magic. Let’s break it down.

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter – This is the star, so make it a good one! I prefer standard commercial brands like Jif or Skippy for this recipe because their stabilizers help with the perfect chewy texture. Natural peanut butter (the kind you have to stir) can make the cookies a bit greasy and spread more.
• 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened – “Softened” is key here! Leave it on the counter for about an hour. It should be cool to the touch but yield easily when you press it. This creams together with the sugars to create a light, airy base for our cookies.
• 1 cup brown sugar, packed – This is our secret weapon for chewiness. The molasses in brown sugar adds moisture and a deep, caramel-like flavor. Pack it firmly into your measuring cup!
• 1/2 cup granulated sugar – The white sugar helps create those delightfully crisp edges and aids in spreading. The combination of the two sugars is non-negotiable for the perfect texture.
• 2 large eggs – They act as a binder, bringing our dough together. Always use large eggs at room temperature for the best incorporation into the creamed butter and sugar.
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract – The flavor enhancer! It rounds out the peanut butter and adds a warm, aromatic depth. Don’t you dare skip it.
• 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour – The structure-builder. I like to fluff my flour with a spoon before scooping and leveling it off with a knife to avoid packing too much in.
• 1 teaspoon baking soda – Our leavening agent! This is what gives the cookies their lift and prevents them from being dense hockey pucks. Make sure yours is fresh for the best rise.

Let’s Get Baking: The Step-by-Step Magic

Okay, team, it’s go time. Follow these steps, and you’ll be a peanut butter cookie hero in no time. I’ve sprinkled in my favorite chef hacks to ensure your success.

1. Preheat and Prep. First things first, get that oven heating to a toasty 350°F (175°C). This ensures a consistent temperature from the moment your cookies go in. Line your baking sheets with parchment paper. Trust me, this is a game-changer for easy cleanup and preventing any sticking. Chef’s Hack: If you have a dark-colored baking sheet, reduce the oven temp by 25°F as they tend to bake faster and can lead to darker bottoms.
2. The Creaming Method. In a large bowl, cream together the peanut butter, softened butter, brown sugar, and granulated sugar. Now, “cream” doesn’t just mean “mix.” You want to beat it on medium-high speed for a good 2-3 minutes until it becomes noticeably lighter in color and fluffy. This step incorporates air, which is crucial for texture! Chef’s Hack: If your butter wasn’t quite soft enough, don’t microwave it! Cut it into chunks and it will come to temp faster.
3. Incorporate the Wet Team. Add the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition. This allows the emulsion to form properly, so your dough doesn’t break. Then, mix in that glorious vanilla extract. Scrape down the sides of the bowl to make sure everything is homogenous.
4. Bring in the Dry Crew. In a separate bowl, whisk together your flour and baking soda. Why whisk? It aerates the flour and evenly distributes the baking soda, so you get a uniform rise. Gradually add this to your wet ingredients, mixing on low speed until *just* combined. The second the flour disappears, stop mixing! Overmixing is the enemy of a tender cookie. Chef’s Hack: For an extra-chewy cookie, let the mixed dough rest in the fridge for 15-20 minutes. This hydrates the flour and reduces spreading.
5. Scoop and Shape. Use a cookie scoop or a tablespoon to portion the dough into 1.5-inch balls. Roll them gently between your palms. Place them about 2 inches apart on your prepared baking sheets—they need their personal space to spread!
6. The Signature Press. Gently flatten each ball of dough slightly with your palm. Then, for that classic look, use a fork to press a criss-cross pattern into the top. I like to dip my fork in a little granulated sugar between presses to prevent sticking and add a tiny sparkle.
7. Bake to Perfection. Bake for 10-12 minutes. Now, listen closely: the cookies are done when the edges are set and lightly golden, but the centers still look soft, puffy, and slightly underdone. They will look perfect to you about 2 minutes *after* you think they need to come out. Chef’s Hack: For super-thick cookies, bang the baking sheet on the oven rack or counter as soon as you take them out. This deflates them just enough and creates wonderful wrinkles.
8. The Crucial Cool-Down. This might be the hardest step! Let the cookies cool on the hot baking sheet for a full 5 minutes. They are still setting up from the residual heat. After that, transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely. This patience rewards you with the ultimate chewy texture.

Sharing the Love: How to Serve These Beauties

Okay, the cookies are cool enough to handle. Now what? The simplest way is piled high on a vintage plate with a cold glass of milk. That’s a classic for a reason. But let’s get creative!

For a next-level dessert, I love serving two warm cookies with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream sandwiched between them for an epic ice cream sandwich. Drizzle a little chocolate sauce over the top, and you’ve got a restaurant-worthy treat. They’re also fantastic crumbled over a bowl of chocolate or coffee ice cream. For a fun party platter, set out small bowls of different dippings—like melted chocolate, caramel sauce, and even a sprinkle of sea salt for the gourmands in your life. However you serve them, do it with a smile. Good food is meant to be shared.

Make It Your Own: Delicious Recipe Variations

Once you’ve mastered the base recipe, the playground is open! Here are a few of my favorite ways to mix things up.

• The Chocolate Lover: Fold in 1 cup of semi-sweet or milk chocolate chips into the dough right at the end. Peanut butter and chocolate is a match made in heaven.
• The Salty-Sweet Fanatic: Press a few flakes of Maldon sea salt onto the top of each cookie right when they come out of the oven. It elevates the peanut butter flavor incredibly.
• The Peanut Butter Cup Devotee: Chop up 6-8 full-sized peanut butter cups and fold them in with the flour. You get little pockets of melty, peanut-buttery chocolate in every bite.
• The “Healthier” Swap: You can replace the all-purpose flour with white whole wheat flour for a nuttier flavor and a fiber boost. The texture will be slightly denser but still delicious.
• The Gluten-Free Friend: Use a 1:1 gluten-free all-purpose flour blend. I’ve had great success with Bob’s Red Mill or King Arthur brands. The cookies might spread a tiny bit less, but they’ll be just as tasty.

From My Kitchen to Yours: A Few Parting Thoughts

This recipe has been a living, evolving thing in my kitchen. I once, in a frantic, out-of-butter situation, used all peanut butter. The result? A delicious, but intensely dense and crumbly cookie that my dog absolutely adored (don’t worry, he only got a tiny, dog-safe piece!). It taught me the importance of butter for that perfect texture. I’ve also learned that while the criss-cross is iconic, it’s not just for looks—it ensures the thick dough bakes evenly in the center. The biggest lesson, though? Always make a double batch. The first one disappears faster than you can say “Feastical.”

Your Questions, Answered!

I’ve made these cookies more times than I can count, and I’ve heard all your brilliant questions. Here are the most common ones.

Q: My cookies spread too much and got flat! What happened?
A: This is usually one of three things: 1) Your butter was too warm or melted. 2) Your baking sheet was still warm from a previous batch. 3) You didn’t use enough flour (be sure to fluff, scoop, and level!). Chilling the dough for 15-30 minutes next time will solve this.

Q: Can I use natural peanut butter?
A: You can, but the texture will be different. Natural peanut butter has more oil and can make the cookies greasier and spread more. If you do, try reducing the butter by a tablespoon or two and definitely chill the dough.

Q: Why are my cookies cakey and puffy?
A: This usually means you over-measured the flour (scooping directly from the bag packs it in) or over-mixed the dough after adding the flour. Mix until *just* combined!

Q: How do I make these cookies extra soft for days?
A: The brown sugar is your best friend for moisture. Also, storing them in an airtight container with a single piece of white bread works miracles! The cookies absorb the moisture from the bread, staying soft for days (the bread will get hard, but your cookies will be perfect).

Thick and Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies : Soft, Buttery, and Totally Addictive

---

• Author: BeauCollier
• Total Time: 30 mins

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

These Thick & Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies are the kind that stop conversations mid-sentence. With a golden, crisp edge and a soft, fudgy center that melts in your mouth, they redefine comfort baking. Inspired by childhood memories and perfected through years of tweaking, this recipe captures everything you love about peanut butter—rich, nutty, and deeply satisfying. No dry, crumbly cookies here—just pure, chewy bliss that’ll make your kitchen smell like heaven.

---

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter (Jif or Skippy for best results)

• ½ cup unsalted butter, softened

• 1 cup packed brown sugar

• ½ cup granulated sugar

• 2 large eggs, room temperature

• 1 tsp vanilla extract

• 1½ cups all-purpose flour

• 1 tsp baking soda

---

Instructions

1. Preheat & Prep
   Heat oven to 350°F (175°C) and line baking sheets with parchment paper.

2. Cream the Base
   Beat peanut butter, butter, brown sugar, and granulated sugar for 2–3 minutes until light and fluffy.

3. Add Wet Ingredients
   Mix in eggs one at a time, then add vanilla. Scrape the bowl to ensure everything’s combined.

4. Add Dry Ingredients
   Whisk together flour and baking soda. Add to the wet mixture, stirring just until no streaks of flour remain. (Don’t overmix!)

5. Scoop & Shape
   Roll dough into 1½-inch balls. Place 2 inches apart on baking sheets. Flatten slightly with your palm, then press a criss-cross pattern using a fork dipped in sugar.

6. Bake & Cool
   Bake 10–12 minutes, until edges are golden but centers still look soft. Cool on the sheet for 5 minutes before transferring to a rack.

Notes

• Chill dough for 15–20 minutes for thicker cookies.

• Add chocolate chips or flaky sea salt for a flavor upgrade.

• Store with a slice of bread to keep cookies soft for days.

• Prep Time: 15 mins
• Cook Time: 12 mins

Nutrition

• Calories: 210 Cal Per Serving

Let’s Talk Nutrition (The Fun Kind!)

Look, we’re here for a delicious cookie, and I believe in enjoying every single bite without guilt. But it’s always good to know what you’re enjoying! This is an approximate breakdown per cookie (based on a batch of 24).

• Calories: 210 – A perfect little energy boost.
• Fat: 12g – Coming from the peanut butter and butter, giving us that satisfying richness.
• Sugar: 14g – The sweet stuff that makes life worth living. The blend of brown and white sugar is key.
• Carbs: 22g – Fuel for your next kitchen dance party while you wait for the next batch to bake.
• Protein: 4g – A nice little bit from the peanut butter and eggs, making these surprisingly satisfying.
• Sodium: 110mg – Just a hint to balance all the flavors.

Remember, friends, food is about more than just numbers. It’s about the joy of baking, the smell filling your home, and the smile on someone’s face when you hand them a warm cookie. That’s the real nutrition.

The Last Crumb: Final Thoughts

And there you have it! My heart and soul in cookie form. This recipe is a testament to the fact that the best foods are often the simplest, made with love and a little bit of know-how. I hope these thick and chewy peanut butter cookies become a staple in your home, just like they are in mine. They’re more than just a recipe; they’re a reminder to slow down, preheat the oven, and create a little moment of deliciousness.

I’d love to hear how your batch turns out! Tag me on social @Feastical or @BeauCollier so I can see your beautiful creations. Now, go forth and bake! Your cookie jar is waiting.

With a full heart and an empty plate,
Beau